In Sociocracy, can we share reasons why someone (who we're not nominating) is NOT qualified for a role in our view?

There are two things to keep in mind here. One is that this can create a harmful group dynamic unless this feedback is delivered with a lot of skill. But more importantly, we don’t think there is any reason to talk about counter-reasons in the nomination round. You can always object IF that person becomes the candidate. Yet, in the nomination round and change round, typically there are several options so why argue about options that are not on the table yet?

For more information, check out our handbook Many Voices One Song sections 3.6.3 and 3.6.4